Last updated: November 2026. Applies to income tax orders under the Income Tax Ordinance 2001, Tax Year 2026 rules. Prepared by the tax and corporate team of My Law Associates, led by Mr. Faisal Mehmood, FPA, with 17 years of experience.
If you plan to file an appeal against FBR order in Pakistan, check your deadline before anything else. Many Pakistani websites still say you have 60 days to appeal to the Appellate Tribunal. That's wrong now. The Finance Act 2024 cut the ATIR deadline from 60 days to 30 days, and taxpayers who trust old blog posts can lose their appeal before it even starts.
For most taxpayers, the first stop is the Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals), and the clock is short at every step. Below we walk through the whole route: who to appeal to, by when, with which papers, and what to do if recovery has already started.
Quick answer: File your first appeal with the Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals), called CIR(A), within 30 days of receiving the FBR order. Pay the tax admitted in your return first. If CIR(A) rules against you, appeal to the Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue (ATIR) within 30 days. Since Finance Act 2025, you may also go straight to ATIR.
| What you need | Time limit | Result |
|---|---|---|
| FBR order, grounds of appeal, proof of tax paid, proof of fee, supporting documents | 30 days from the date you received the order | CIR(A) confirms, changes or cancels the order |
| CIR(A) order, Tribunal appeal form, fee proof, earlier papers | 30 days from the date you received the CIR(A) order | ATIR decides the appeal, with a 90-day target for decision |
| ATIR order and a question of law | 60 days from receiving the ATIR judgment | High Court rules on the legal point only |
Which FBR orders can you appeal?
You can appeal most final orders that create or increase tax, or impose a penalty. The common ones we see in our Lahore office are listed below.
Amended assessment (section 122) and best judgment assessment (section 121)
A section 122 order means FBR has re-worked your tax for a past year. Usually it adds income or disallows expenses, so the tax goes up. An FBR amended assessment appeal is the most common appeal we handle.
A section 121 order is a "best judgment" assessment. FBR estimates your tax because you didn't file a return or didn't reply to a notice. You can appeal that too.
Penalty, default surcharge and withholding orders
Orders imposing a penalty or default surcharge (extra charge for late payment) can be appealed. So can section 161 orders, where FBR says you failed to deduct or deposit withholding tax.
What about section 120 and notices?
Under section 120, your filed return is treated as an assessment order. Problems usually start only when FBR later amends it. A show-cause notice is not a final order. You reply to the notice; the appeal comes after the order is passed.
What are the deadlines for CIR(A), ATIR and the High Court?
You get 30 days for CIR(A), 30 days for ATIR and 60 days for the High Court. Each period runs from the day the order reached you.
| Forum | Law | Deadline | Covers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commissioner Inland Revenue (Appeals) | Section 127 | 30 days | Facts and law |
| Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue | Section 131 | 30 days (was 60 before Finance Act 2024) | Facts and law |
| High Court reference | Section 133 | 60 days from the ATIR judgment | Questions of law only |
Why do many websites still show 60 days for ATIR?
Because the old law said 60 days, and many pages were never updated. The change came through Finance Act 2024. The High Court period of 60 days is confirmed in FBR Circular 01 of 2025-26 on Finance Act 2025 income tax changes. Our honest advice: treat every tax appeal as a 30-day job.
How do you count the 30 days?
Count from the date of service, meaning the day the order reached you. That is not always the date printed on the order. If an order dated 2 January was served on you on 5 January, the 30 days end on 4 February.
Keep the courier receipt, the email, or a screenshot from IRIS (FBR's online portal). In our practice, we set an internal deadline 7 to 10 days early, so there's time to fix a missing document.
What if you miss the deadline?
Both CIR(A) and ATIR can accept a late appeal if you show "sufficient cause", meaning a real reason you couldn't file on time. You must explain the delay in writing, with proof such as medical records. Acceptance is not automatic, so don't rely on it.
How to file an appeal against FBR order with CIR(A) in Pakistan: step by step
An appeal to Commissioner Appeals in Pakistan follows seven practical steps. Each step exists for a reason, and skipping one is how most appeals go wrong.
Step 1: Read the order and list your objections
Go through the order line by line. Mark each addition or disallowance and note why you disagree. Sort your points into three groups: wrong facts, wrong law, or unfair procedure, such as no proper notice before the order.
Step 2: Pay the tax admitted in your return
Under section 127(2), you can't appeal an assessment until you've paid the tax due under section 137(1). In simple words, pay the tax you yourself declared in your return. The disputed extra amount is what the appeal is about.
Step 3: Write the grounds of appeal
The memorandum of appeal is the written paper that tells CIR(A) what's wrong with the order. Each ground should be one clear objection. "The order is illegal" is too vague. "The officer added bank deposits as income although they were loan receipts, proved by the attached agreement" gives CIR(A) something to decide.
Step 4: Attach documents and proof of fee
Attach the order, at least one certified copy, the fee proof and your evidence. The full checklist is further below.
Step 5: File online or at the CIR(A) office
Section 127 lets FBR require e-filing of appeals, and many appeals are now filed through the online system. Physical filing at the CIR(A) office is also used. Either way, keep the acknowledgment with the filing date. That paper proves you met the deadline.
Step 6: Ask for a stay if recovery has started
If FBR has started recovery, apply for a stay of recovery. This is a pause on collection while the appeal is pending. It is a separate request, not part of the appeal itself.
Step 7: Attend hearings and collect the order
CIR(A) will send hearing notices. You or your representative explain the grounds and answer questions. Bring the original documents. After hearing, CIR(A) passes an order, called the Order-in-Appeal. It should be a speaking order, which means it gives clear reasons.
If this feels like a lot under a 30-day clock, our team handles tax appeals to CIR(A) and ATIR, FBR notices and audit from drafting to hearing.
How does the appeal system work, in plain words?
The system gives you a fresh look at your case by someone who didn't make the original order. It works a bit like asking a different teacher to re-mark a disputed exam paper.
CIR(A) is a senior officer separate from the assessing officer. ATIR is a court-like body with judicial and accountant members. The High Court comes last and only checks whether the law was applied correctly. It does not re-check the facts.
That's why evidence matters most at the first two levels. If a bank statement wasn't shown at CIR(A) or ATIR, it's very hard to use later.
Should you go to CIR(A) first or directly to ATIR?
Since Finance Act 2025, you can choose. The earlier rules based on the tax amount (pecuniary jurisdiction) were withdrawn, so any taxpayer may file before CIR(A) or directly before ATIR.
| Point | CIR(A) first | Directly to ATIR |
|---|---|---|
| Chances on facts | Two levels can review your facts | One level reviews your facts |
| Speed | Longer overall route | Shorter route, 90-day decision target |
| Best for | Disputes about records, evidence or calculations | Mainly legal disputes, or urgent large demands |
| Risk | More time under dispute | You give up the first appeal stage |
Our general view: when the dispute is about facts or missing documents, CIR(A) first is usually safer. You get two chances to prove your numbers. The choice is made when you file, so get advice before you pick a forum.
What is the ATIR appeal process after CIR(A) rules against you?
The ATIR appeal process starts with a written appeal filed within 30 days of receiving the CIR(A) order. You file it with the Tribunal's Registrar in the prescribed form, with the prescribed fee.
Which form do you use?
Under the ATIR Rules 2010, the memorandum of appeal goes in Form A or Form B. It is verified and filed with the Registrar. A late appeal needs a written explanation of the delay.
What is the ATIR fee?
Section 131(3) fixes the fee, and it is different for companies and other taxpayers. Fees can change through a Finance Act, so confirm the current amount with the ATIR Registrar or our team before paying.
Can ATIR stop recovery?
Yes, on your application. Under section 131, tax stays payable unless ATIR stays recovery. So apply as soon as the appeal is filed if FBR is pressing for payment.
What can ATIR decide?
ATIR has a 90-day target to decide appeals. It can confirm the order, change it, cancel it, or send the case back (remand) for a fresh decision.
What documents do you need for an FBR tax appeal?
You need the appeal papers, proof of payment and proof for every ground. The FBR income tax appeals brochure lists the core items.
- Memorandum and grounds of appeal, signed and verified
- Copy of the order appealed against, with at least one certified copy
- Proof of appeal fee paid
- Proof of tax paid under section 137(1), for assessment appeals
- For ATIR: copies of the CIR(A) order as well
- Your earlier replies to FBR notices
- Bank statements, sales and purchase invoices, withholding tax certificates
- Copy of CNIC and NTN details
Extra papers for companies and AOPs
A company should attach a board resolution authorizing the appeal and the representative. A partnership or AOP (Association of Persons) should attach an authority letter signed by the partners. Salaried people and sole proprietors simply sign an authority letter if someone represents them.
On privacy: share only the documents the appeal needs. We follow a privacy-first approach and work under a written authority for each case.

Does filing an appeal stop FBR recovery?
No. Filing an appeal does not stop recovery on its own. You must ask CIR(A) or ATIR for a stay of recovery in a separate application.
We've seen taxpayers file a strong appeal and still face a frozen bank account, because no one asked for a stay. Stay periods are limited by law and can be extended only in set cases, so check the current rules with us when you file.
What are the most common mistakes in tax appeals?
Most failed appeals fail on basics, not on law. These are the mistakes we see most often, and how to fix them.
| Mistake | Why it hurts | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Using the old 60-day ATIR limit | Appeal becomes time-barred | Treat every stage as 30 days, except the High Court |
| Not paying the tax admitted in the return | Assessment appeal can't be filed | Pay under section 137(1) and keep the challan |
| Vague grounds | Nothing specific for the forum to decide | One clear ground per issue, with evidence |
| No certified copy of the order | Filing may be returned | Apply for a certified copy early |
| No reply to the earlier show-cause notice | Weak record from the start | Always reply with documents before the order |
| No stay request | Recovery continues during appeal | File a stay application with the appeal |
Pro tips from our appeals desk
- Check IRIS for notices every week. Many problems start with a notice nobody opened.
- Reply to section 122 show-cause notices with documents, not just a letter.
- File returns on time through a reliable filer and income tax return service, so fewer orders arise.
- Ask about the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) committee. It is a panel that can settle some disputes without a full hearing.
- You can add grounds later, but only with permission. Draft carefully the first time.
How is a sales tax appeal different?
The route is similar, but the law is different. Sales tax appeals go to CIR(A) under section 45B and then to the Tribunal under section 46 of the Sales Tax Act 1990. Federal excise appeals to CIR(A) fall under section 34 of the FED Act.
| Point | Income tax | Sales tax |
|---|---|---|
| First appeal | CIR(A), section 127 | CIR(A), section 45B |
| Second appeal | ATIR, section 131 | ATIR, section 46 |
| High Court | Section 133, law only | Reference on law only |
Some sales tax appeals are now "faceless" under section 45C, handled without meeting the officer in person. These sections have been replaced more than once, so confirm the period in force with us before filing.
What if ATIR also rules against you?
You can file a reference in the High Court under section 133 within 60 days of receiving the ATIR judgment. It covers questions of law only, such as how a section should be read.
This stage needs a lawyer to frame the legal question properly. Our law services team can review whether a real legal point exists before you spend time and money.
How can My Law Associates help with your appeal?
We draft and file tax appeals to CIR(A) and ATIR, request stays, and represent clients at hearings. Since 2010, we've represented clients before field tax authorities, the Federal Board of Revenue, appellate forums and the Tariff Commission.
Our team of more than 25 professionals includes Chartered and Fellow Public Accountants, Cost and Management Accountants and law graduates. We work with more than 130 client organizations in sectors such as energy, IT, trading, manufacturing and construction. See our full list of tax and compliance services for related support.
We can't promise a result in any appeal. What we can do is meet the deadline, build a clear record, and present your case properly.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many days do I have to appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals)?
You have 30 days from the date the order was served on you. This comes from section 127 of the Income Tax Ordinance 2001.
Is the ATIR deadline 30 or 60 days?
It is 30 days. Finance Act 2024 reduced it from 60 days, so ignore older pages that still say 60.
Can I appeal directly to ATIR without going to CIR(A)?
Yes. Since Finance Act 2025, you may file before CIR(A) or directly before ATIR. You give up the first appeal stage if you skip it.
Do I have to pay tax before filing an appeal?
Yes, for assessment appeals. You must pay the tax due under section 137(1), which is the tax admitted in your return.
Does filing an appeal stop FBR recovery?
No. You must apply separately to CIR(A) or ATIR for a stay of recovery.
What is the fee for an appeal to CIR(A) and ATIR?
The fee is set by law and differs for companies and other taxpayers. Confirm the current amount before filing, as a Finance Act can change it.
What if I miss the 30-day deadline?
You can ask for the delay to be excused for sufficient cause. Give the reason in writing with proof, but acceptance is not guaranteed.
Your next step
An FBR order is serious, but it isn't the final word. Act within 30 days, pay the admitted tax, write clear grounds and ask for a stay if needed.
Need help with this? Book a free consultation with My Law Associates. Call 0334-4007652 or 042-35786746, email faisalfpa@gmail.com, or visit our office at Eden Heights, Jail Road, Lahore. Our team will review your case and handle the complete process for you.
This article is for general information. Every case is different; please consult our team before acting.